Eliminate unevaluatedProperties behind a single \ branch

[Vansh-kap-98]

unevaluated_properties_to_additional_properties only fires when
unevaluatedProperties has no applicator sibling at all, which does not happen
on real schemas. All 33 unevaluatedProperties occurrences in the OMC benchmark
sit next to allOf: [ { $ref } ], so the keyword survives canonicalisation.

This handles that shape. Based on arXiv:2503.11288v1 ("Elimination of annotation
dependencies in validation for Modern JSON Schema"), which I read for this: it is
the paper's cheapest non-trivial case, where a single branch means there is
nothing to intersect and the referenced schema's evaluated property set is
exactly the names its properties spells out.

Renaming alone would be wrong, since additionalProperties only consults
syntactically adjacent properties/patternProperties and the $ref's
properties are not adjacent. The referenced names are merged into the local
properties as true schemas first; validation still comes from the untouched
$ref.

The rewrite applies only when the target is statically characterisable: no
in-place applicator or reference of its own, no unevaluated*, no
additionalProperties, no non-empty patternProperties. Targets whose
required is not already covered by properties are skipped, since
required_properties_in_properties would widen them later, as are legacy
dialects, which grow an implicit additionalProperties.

Limits: converts only the terminal hop of a $ref chain (in a -> b -> c only
b -> c), does not touch unevaluatedItems, and does not affect
E2E_Evaluator_*, which compiles the raw schema without canonicalising.

Effect: benchmark/e2e/omc/schema.json goes from 33 unevaluatedProperties to
0 after canonicalisation. No site in benchmark/e2e/openapi/schema.json
converts.

[cubic-dev-ai]

1 issue found across 4 files

Prompt for AI agents (unresolved issues)

Check if these issues are valid — if so, understand the root cause of each and fix them. If appropriate, use sub-agents to investigate and fix each issue separately.


<file name="test/canonicalizer/canonicalizer_2019_09_test.cc">

<violation number="1" location="test/canonicalizer/canonicalizer_2019_09_test.cc:749">
P3: Only the happy path and two negative cases (anyOf target, additionalProperties target) are tested, but the rewrite stays sound only because of several other guard conditions that the PR description explicitly calls out. Add "stays" tests for a target with `required` not fully covered by `properties`, a non-empty `patternProperties`, an in-place applicator such as `items`/`contains`, and a legacy dialect (e.g. draft-04), plus a top-level sibling `unevaluatedItems`. These guard conditions are what prevent the rewrite from corrupting semantics, so leaving them untested hides regressions in exactly the logic this PR exists to add. The rule also applies to 2020-12, so the same cases belong in canonicalizer_2020_12_test.cc.</violation>
</file>

<sub>Reply with feedback, questions, or to request a fix.

Re-trigger cubic</sub>

[cubic-dev-ai]

P3: Only the happy path and two negative cases (anyOf target, additionalProperties target) are tested, but the rewrite stays sound only because of several other guard conditions that the PR description explicitly calls out. Add "stays" tests for a target with required not fully covered by properties, a non-empty patternProperties, an in-place applicator such as items/contains, and a legacy dialect (e.g. draft-04), plus a top-level sibling unevaluatedItems. These guard conditions are what prevent the rewrite from corrupting semantics, so leaving them untested hides regressions in exactly the logic this PR exists to add. The rule also applies to 2020-12, so the same cases belong in canonicalizer_2020_12_test.cc.

Prompt for AI agents

Check if this issue is valid — if so, understand the root cause and fix it. At test/canonicalizer/canonicalizer_2019_09_test.cc, line 749:

<comment>Only the happy path and two negative cases (anyOf target, additionalProperties target) are tested, but the rewrite stays sound only because of several other guard conditions that the PR description explicitly calls out. Add "stays" tests for a target with `required` not fully covered by `properties`, a non-empty `patternProperties`, an in-place applicator such as `items`/`contains`, and a legacy dialect (e.g. draft-04), plus a top-level sibling `unevaluatedItems`. These guard conditions are what prevent the rewrite from corrupting semantics, so leaving them untested hides regressions in exactly the logic this PR exists to add. The rule also applies to 2020-12, so the same cases belong in canonicalizer_2020_12_test.cc.</comment>

<file context>
@@ -746,6 +746,187 @@ TEST(items_implicit_1) {
   CANONICALIZE_AND_VALIDATE(document, expected, compiled_metaschema());
 }
 
+TEST(unevaluated_properties_single_ref_to_additional_properties) {
+  auto document = sourcemeta::core::parse_json(R"JSON({
+    "$schema": "https://json-schema.org/draft/2019-09/schema",
</file context>

[github-actions]

Benchmark (macos/llvm)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d818b8b	Previous: 49094a0	Ratio
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language	3661199.1853655265 ns/iter	3898398.746113877 ns/iter	0.94
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language_To_JSON	16606819.734691698 ns/iter	13966395.826921247 ns/iter	1.19
Schema_Frame_WoT_References	3667971.467980642 ns/iter	3006915.2031249045 ns/iter	1.22
Schema_Frame_OMC_References	15975480.916665673 ns/iter	14316033.323078813 ns/iter	1.12
Schema_Frame_OMC_Pointers	33893204.695657365 ns/iter	27812091.346154727 ns/iter	1.22
Schema_Frame_OMC_Locations	13155449.404762078 ns/iter	10922380.681818416 ns/iter	1.20
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations	36815377.470595516 ns/iter	30590728.260874484 ns/iter	1.20
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Root	293.14816143919074 ns/iter	218.30135963303573 ns/iter	1.34
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_References	27614987.83332665 ns/iter	20003728.594591282 ns/iter	1.38
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_Reachable	286473458.5000406 ns/iter	220804389.33335245 ns/iter	1.30
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations_To_JSON	35179249.99999877 ns/iter	32605276.04166441 ns/iter	1.08
Schema_Frame_Many_Resources_References	183191416.66665927 ns/iter	177325266.80001682 ns/iter	1.03
Schema_Frame_Deeply_Nested_References	19540709.60605901 ns/iter	16762788.208334692 ns/iter	1.17
Schema_Bundle_Meta_2020_12	930583.1088978193 ns/iter	651770.3481493855 ns/iter	1.43
Schema_Bundle_Many_Remotes_With_Fragments	12177213.015883397 ns/iter	7319607.5918345675 ns/iter	1.66
Schema_Format_ISO_Language_To_JSON	38787041.84615764 ns/iter	32779859.8636119 ns/iter	1.18
E2E_Compiler_adaptivecard	58721854.10000838 ns/iter	37181476.56249471 ns/iter	1.58
E2E_Compiler_ansible_meta	17758490.071428023 ns/iter	11782333.955223484 ns/iter	1.51
E2E_Compiler_aws_cdk	319453.2755659616 ns/iter	174354.14904455477 ns/iter	1.83
E2E_Compiler_babelrc	2023475.337531755 ns/iter	1004459.4208810364 ns/iter	2.01
E2E_Compiler_clang_format	15493153.656247927 ns/iter	7319024.92523268 ns/iter	2.12
E2E_Compiler_cmake_presets	34799659.75000709 ns/iter	18132069.44444801 ns/iter	1.92
E2E_Compiler_code_climate	1423371.38084639 ns/iter	853304.6095744503 ns/iter	1.67
E2E_Compiler_cql2	13839008.510205753 ns/iter	7572579.121213292 ns/iter	1.83
E2E_Compiler_cspell	21066877.840909954 ns/iter	15446161.914288886 ns/iter	1.36
E2E_Compiler_cypress	4434839.820754955 ns/iter	1916226.027160407 ns/iter	2.31
E2E_Compiler_deno	8538054.972221844 ns/iter	3867149.595121524 ns/iter	2.21
E2E_Compiler_dependabot	3094321.0105631254 ns/iter	1733003.608225154 ns/iter	1.79
E2E_Compiler_draft_04	2253777.476703053 ns/iter	1465296.5686278264 ns/iter	1.54
E2E_Compiler_fabric_mod	3746869.442424709 ns/iter	2362499.1749176555 ns/iter	1.59
E2E_Compiler_geojson	20414949.083336372 ns/iter	13548993.945455963 ns/iter	1.51
E2E_Compiler_gitpod_configuration	3584999.273256958 ns/iter	2203292.032257534 ns/iter	1.63
E2E_Compiler_helm_chart_lock	585045.1454033958 ns/iter	334320.970599546 ns/iter	1.75
E2E_Compiler_importmap	214080.0389754513 ns/iter	156205.89663355175 ns/iter	1.37
E2E_Compiler_jasmine	828399.2348993052 ns/iter	547017.735204928 ns/iter	1.51
E2E_Compiler_jshintrc	2177725.649350914 ns/iter	1593441.6828751895 ns/iter	1.37
E2E_Compiler_jsconfig	14262348.039214795 ns/iter	10212384.615384415 ns/iter	1.40
E2E_Compiler_krakend	124164779.71428971 ns/iter	81890679.10000177 ns/iter	1.52
E2E_Compiler_lazygit	27590528.285713844 ns/iter	19616618.511109766 ns/iter	1.41
E2E_Compiler_lerna	1146984.2740384506 ns/iter	816641.6479029745 ns/iter	1.40
E2E_Compiler_nest_cli	6082489.676189305 ns/iter	3404827.6596858213 ns/iter	1.79
E2E_Compiler_omc	156935406.2499997 ns/iter	95982315.57142104 ns/iter	1.64
E2E_Compiler_omnisharp	5243514.985611111 ns/iter	3161300.1302090995 ns/iter	1.66
E2E_Compiler_openapi	27728344.82758644 ns/iter	13928161.680000814 ns/iter	1.99
E2E_Compiler_pre_commit_hooks	2295329.8141893307 ns/iter	1581207.991803314 ns/iter	1.45
E2E_Compiler_pulumi	3269618.8118812465 ns/iter	1819110.0099253394 ns/iter	1.80
E2E_Compiler_semantic_release	995107.9034482877 ns/iter	761464.8318583397 ns/iter	1.31
E2E_Compiler_stale	798134.2191193443 ns/iter	573410.3483754986 ns/iter	1.39
E2E_Compiler_stylecop	3632033.0056180484 ns/iter	2916618.181494686 ns/iter	1.25
E2E_Compiler_tmuxinator	1083258.669355165 ns/iter	942575.3943868581 ns/iter	1.15
E2E_Compiler_ui5	45086127.4705938 ns/iter	37460173.210523576 ns/iter	1.20
E2E_Compiler_ui5_manifest	260758291.99999136 ns/iter	238118333.33328044 ns/iter	1.10
E2E_Compiler_unreal_engine_uproject	2483124.564460552 ns/iter	1946922.8006139097 ns/iter	1.28
E2E_Compiler_users_array	501305.0426135767 ns/iter	386046.4907062612 ns/iter	1.30
E2E_Compiler_vercel	8055469.881189157 ns/iter	6139858.070312698 ns/iter	1.31
E2E_Compiler_yamllint	129149.4589386337 ns/iter	108689.48862908121 ns/iter	1.19
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	34906.14444919334 ns/iter	22617.065716663335 ns/iter	1.54
E2E_Evaluator_ansible_meta	304589.11267606344 ns/iter	192967.57466814652 ns/iter	1.58
E2E_Evaluator_aws_cdk	55311.31660000029 ns/iter	43901.258998188954 ns/iter	1.26
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	115365.65012897395 ns/iter	98747.61658099794 ns/iter	1.17
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum_criminal_case	1209414.79353911 ns/iter	928115.7521577767 ns/iter	1.30
E2E_Evaluator_clang_format	121870.63167156768 ns/iter	94126.444595504 ns/iter	1.29
E2E_Evaluator_cmake_presets	6158653.749998849 ns/iter	4799457.095237986 ns/iter	1.28
E2E_Evaluator_code_climate	208098.76380851344 ns/iter	164265.8548717708 ns/iter	1.27
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	216242.5833917796 ns/iter	155714.9708265592 ns/iter	1.39
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	695240.3038461888 ns/iter	564164.5729803233 ns/iter	1.23
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	192115.21534710584 ns/iter	155102.6668260967 ns/iter	1.24
E2E_Evaluator_deno	363988.120567383 ns/iter	285899.64078749006 ns/iter	1.27
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	401110.42247842834 ns/iter	294482.5171178404 ns/iter	1.36
E2E_Evaluator_draft_04	8072066.8604657855 ns/iter	5602991.186992582 ns/iter	1.44
E2E_Evaluator_fabric_mod	725175.2531894125 ns/iter	565056.8663999366 ns/iter	1.28
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	12416041.057969013 ns/iter	9491768.893331027 ns/iter	1.31
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod_configuration	302285.44327643234 ns/iter	211379.433390995 ns/iter	1.43
E2E_Evaluator_helm_chart_lock	357198.1589146813 ns/iter	318613.51217085967 ns/iter	1.12
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	57060.483300006126 ns/iter	45332.051805042676 ns/iter	1.26
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	150940.5931693745 ns/iter	106267.32526520717 ns/iter	1.42
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	1563945.9706959222 ns/iter	1097255.222841485 ns/iter	1.43
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	449643.91626289615 ns/iter	333522.08268856525 ns/iter	1.35
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	227402.96965605905 ns/iter	158701.21612615633 ns/iter	1.43
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	178867.67802112285 ns/iter	115521.58377394866 ns/iter	1.55
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	213165.79127895043 ns/iter	141205.14220184527 ns/iter	1.51
E2E_Evaluator_nest_cli	229645.31306023826 ns/iter	152496.63739441 ns/iter	1.51
E2E_Evaluator_omc	19305.93219123189 ns/iter	16460.93984408428 ns/iter	1.17
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	573950.139166565 ns/iter	628056.5419999675 ns/iter	0.91
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	9026022.942031847 ns/iter	10912404.594203021 ns/iter	0.83
E2E_Evaluator_pre_commit_hooks	512103.9589998872 ns/iter	541407.246051572 ns/iter	0.95
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	710534.5612682865 ns/iter	593845.2378101305 ns/iter	1.20
E2E_Evaluator_semantic_release	99937.37280272752 ns/iter	82090.36355085838 ns/iter	1.22
E2E_Evaluator_stale	152320.10367214415 ns/iter	140888.8370907575 ns/iter	1.08
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	305430.23913043446 ns/iter	258931.43154366312 ns/iter	1.18
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	125006.73861743225 ns/iter	77121.88498119569 ns/iter	1.62
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	593050.3248639413 ns/iter	410725.3362988014 ns/iter	1.44
E2E_Evaluator_ui5_manifest	1976439.9578651832 ns/iter	1981835.2307692764 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_unreal_engine_uproject	387275.21765687456 ns/iter	487601.55382912693 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_users_array	499124.7501666179 ns/iter	538146.7990235345 ns/iter	0.93
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	311859.37913477997 ns/iter	250822.30652331753 ns/iter	1.24
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	9454.25564311246 ns/iter	8859.928913296457 ns/iter	1.07
JSONLD_Catalog_Simple	20842297.44444125 ns/iter	17996897.92500203 ns/iter	1.16
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Agreeing	21421034.090907957 ns/iter	18184275.641027477 ns/iter	1.18
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Shadowing	26031052.481483936 ns/iter	28690651.785707034 ns/iter	0.91
Micro_Draft4_Meta_1_No_Callback	188.7995031717174 ns/iter	161.87952192377531 ns/iter	1.17
Micro_Draft4_Required_Properties	839.4238243953363 ns/iter	755.5643746369121 ns/iter	1.11
Micro_Draft4_Many_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	22.700857840481955 ns/iter	18.706606681063885 ns/iter	1.21
Micro_Draft4_Few_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	11.087811116694889 ns/iter	11.362381567540728 ns/iter	0.98
Micro_Draft4_Items_Schema	289.0880326502918 ns/iter	282.7073189732871 ns/iter	1.02
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Object	2.1873306373929924 ns/iter	1.8191577150293 ns/iter	1.20
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Optional	376.3580123733252 ns/iter	336.1481227267843 ns/iter	1.12
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Closed	261.1429290560986 ns/iter	259.00834676596867 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Required	407.6470920120755 ns/iter	331.8506552065959 ns/iter	1.23
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Closed	62.75017077297406 ns/iter	54.443024965271974 ns/iter	1.15
Micro_Draft4_Non_Recursive_Ref	16.27714814757746 ns/iter	13.338329285566475 ns/iter	1.22
Micro_Draft4_Pattern_Properties_Empty	210.02131752289998 ns/iter	174.35363441112548 ns/iter	1.20
Micro_Draft4_Ref_To_Single_Property	14.488227394395112 ns/iter	11.408587963874266 ns/iter	1.27
Micro_Draft4_Additional_Properties_Type	31.905217114045342 ns/iter	29.429160823388422 ns/iter	1.08
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Oneof	47.4945852115611 ns/iter	41.09601143743633 ns/iter	1.16
Micro_Draft4_Short_Enum	8.052775212515671 ns/iter	7.182849069861677 ns/iter	1.12
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum	13.968119462716098 ns/iter	11.414638412701839 ns/iter	1.22
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum_Short_Strings	9.093611523669095 ns/iter	8.629395488403812 ns/iter	1.05
Micro_Draft4_Type_Object	4.533415385336528 ns/iter	3.545823704913021 ns/iter	1.28
Micro_Draft4_Ref_Single_100	1203979.6660957725 ns/iter	1047763.5973055196 ns/iter	1.15
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Ref_Many_Nested	900775.2273224032 ns/iter	662985.8212927728 ns/iter	1.36
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Wrap	1059195.511834534 ns/iter	878351.9950370747 ns/iter	1.21
Micro_Draft6_Property_Names	113.59307113355173 ns/iter	97.61235753884594 ns/iter	1.16
Micro_Draft6_Compile_FHIR	7242377000.000033 ns/iter	5821016500.000042 ns/iter	1.24
Micro_Draft7_If_Then_Else	22.90707633501495 ns/iter	20.17473481196204 ns/iter	1.14
Micro_2019_09_Unevaluated_Properties	41.16844976804258 ns/iter	34.534518408251806 ns/iter	1.19
Micro_2019_09_Compile_Wrap	100720678.57143858 ns/iter	95090953.12500903 ns/iter	1.06
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref	707.5562191479501 ns/iter	643.4641515914345 ns/iter	1.10
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref_Single	4.3152005104985305 ns/iter	3.676134098205469 ns/iter	1.17
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Mask	890.4061593391065 ns/iter	821.9261104362126 ns/iter	1.08
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotations	51534.78671743723 ns/iter	61368.58916256635 ns/iter	0.84
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotation_Dropping	1214939.9078725993 ns/iter	1272888.8888887013 ns/iter	0.95
Micro_2020_12_Compile_NonCircular_Shared_Refs	476501.2963224398 ns/iter	454852.2336145103 ns/iter	1.05
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric	5073.639159998038 ns/iter	6019.041332544765 ns/iter	0.84
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_SimpleOutput	30780.270959693244 ns/iter	31375.35693661389 ns/iter	0.98
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_TraceOutput	13445.884586621924 ns/iter	15432.307999316492 ns/iter	0.87
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail	87.96279449833405 ns/iter	97.0299398161225 ns/iter	0.91
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail_SimpleOutput	2681.230107897262 ns/iter	2543.713414095277 ns/iter	1.05
TestSuite_Parse_WoT	17713630.946429607 ns/iter	11796219.934426442 ns/iter	1.50
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_ISO_Language_Set_3	171014177.24995828 ns/iter	160282104.2499727 ns/iter	1.07
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_OMC	51040522.26667287 ns/iter	35157697.89999013 ns/iter	1.45
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_KrakenD	601405833.0001717 ns/iter	546124896.0000376 ns/iter	1.10
Alterschema_Apply_Readibility_KrakenD	55447312290.999886 ns/iter	47269789040.99997 ns/iter	1.17
Alterschema_Check_Invalid_External_Refs	160424656.25002933 ns/iter	166118383.20000058 ns/iter	0.97
Alterschema_Check_Resolvable_External_Refs	154733.15888300832 ns/iter	183894.21679741688 ns/iter	0.84

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[github-actions]

JavaScript (macos/llvm)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d818b8b	Previous: 49094a0	Ratio
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	156094 ns	111060 ns	1.41
E2E_Evaluator_ansible-meta	600073 ns	384001 ns	1.56
E2E_Evaluator_aws-cdk	183402 ns	151089 ns	1.21
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	415125 ns	285315 ns	1.45
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum-criminal-case	1881134 ns	1708042 ns	1.10
E2E_Evaluator_clang-format	251908 ns	210751 ns	1.20
E2E_Evaluator_cmake-presets	26828084 ns	17032443 ns	1.58
E2E_Evaluator_code-climate	633886 ns	620136 ns	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	1531201 ns	1619496 ns	0.95
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	1742232 ns	1877806 ns	0.93
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	895263 ns	835858 ns	1.07
E2E_Evaluator_deno	1194239 ns	1139239 ns	1.05
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	947100 ns	1060402 ns	0.89
E2E_Evaluator_draft-04	22224524 ns	19060252 ns	1.17
E2E_Evaluator_fabric-mod	2368145 ns	1887526 ns	1.25
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	23447635 ns	18801795 ns	1.25
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod-configuration	747728 ns	584546 ns	1.28
E2E_Evaluator_helm-chart-lock	1146450 ns	1113339 ns	1.03
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	348939 ns	276649 ns	1.26
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	251929 ns	255608 ns	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	1088342 ns	1117603 ns	0.97
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	2516236 ns	2794772 ns	0.90
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	580161 ns	710283 ns	0.82
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	377845 ns	500339 ns	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	503273 ns	525907 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_nest-cli	640754 ns	516750 ns	1.24
E2E_Evaluator_omc	128830 ns	112912 ns	1.14
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	1384000 ns	1298006 ns	1.07
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	41935620 ns	34560999 ns	1.21
E2E_Evaluator_pre-commit-hooks	1733416 ns	1914572 ns	0.91
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	1883844 ns	2191302 ns	0.86
E2E_Evaluator_semantic-release	221756 ns	222878 ns	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_stale	409200 ns	382786 ns	1.07
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	1105027 ns	1052026 ns	1.05
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	202391 ns	317677 ns	0.64
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	1922286 ns	3134921 ns	0.61
E2E_Evaluator_ui5-manifest	10895216 ns	17883780 ns	0.61
E2E_Evaluator_unreal-engine-uproject	1362406 ns	1916764 ns	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_users-array	2941263 ns	4612854 ns	0.64
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	1108140 ns	1224090 ns	0.91
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	27156 ns	27440 ns	0.99

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[github-actions]

Benchmark (linux/llvm)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d818b8b	Previous: 49094a0	Ratio
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language	2279189.750809139 ns/iter	3517474.4371862113 ns/iter	0.65
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language_To_JSON	8950323.428571032 ns/iter	12357564.732143698 ns/iter	0.72
Schema_Frame_WoT_References	1250396.1270124791 ns/iter	1781748.758354697 ns/iter	0.70
Schema_Frame_OMC_References	5471966.244094909 ns/iter	7829601.12359576 ns/iter	0.70
Schema_Frame_OMC_Pointers	10305115.39705886 ns/iter	14405908.367347347 ns/iter	0.72
Schema_Frame_OMC_Locations	4680619.509933545 ns/iter	6787139.932038309 ns/iter	0.69
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations	26525203.074072577 ns/iter	31830225.954541385 ns/iter	0.83
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Root	194.36458393430814 ns/iter	272.4270024010185 ns/iter	0.71
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_References	9488821.666667199 ns/iter	12194710.210527167 ns/iter	0.78
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_Reachable	77546397.19998977 ns/iter	104703507.71431315 ns/iter	0.74
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations_To_JSON	22134755.4333344 ns/iter	22867564.200002257 ns/iter	0.97
Schema_Frame_Many_Resources_References	85409943.99999847 ns/iter	112613014.50000852 ns/iter	0.76
Schema_Frame_Deeply_Nested_References	6449730.327103128 ns/iter	8925966.49367113 ns/iter	0.72
Schema_Bundle_Meta_2020_12	300666.2980638667 ns/iter	444990.1768445715 ns/iter	0.68
Schema_Bundle_Many_Remotes_With_Fragments	3788146.956286128 ns/iter	5235304.022559995 ns/iter	0.72
Schema_Format_ISO_Language_To_JSON	28845360.62500113 ns/iter	34778385.40000562 ns/iter	0.83
E2E_Compiler_adaptivecard	21311101.939393967 ns/iter	26344430.961536054 ns/iter	0.81
E2E_Compiler_ansible_meta	5833110.866666877 ns/iter	8315772.702380693 ns/iter	0.70
E2E_Compiler_aws_cdk	91906.80186817468 ns/iter	127889.09542960742 ns/iter	0.72
E2E_Compiler_babelrc	507962.11661807407 ns/iter	757537.1256772241 ns/iter	0.67
E2E_Compiler_clang_format	3950787.7288134797 ns/iter	5617758.338710319 ns/iter	0.70
E2E_Compiler_cmake_presets	8342179.10843459 ns/iter	12099683.25862135 ns/iter	0.69
E2E_Compiler_code_climate	370528.5047720041 ns/iter	549990.5522387923 ns/iter	0.67
E2E_Compiler_cql2	3905681.837079044 ns/iter	5768914.9579835255 ns/iter	0.68
E2E_Compiler_cspell	6325844.62162081 ns/iter	9036852.10389599 ns/iter	0.70
E2E_Compiler_cypress	839245.4871795545 ns/iter	1343116.177820316 ns/iter	0.62
E2E_Compiler_deno	1807427.9507773877 ns/iter	2718952.6420231694 ns/iter	0.66
E2E_Compiler_dependabot	699077.245685242 ns/iter	1045838.2786885696 ns/iter	0.67
E2E_Compiler_draft_04	613172.0864197906 ns/iter	991673.7538896238 ns/iter	0.62
E2E_Compiler_fabric_mod	1100784.4047618338 ns/iter	1758918.809045083 ns/iter	0.63
E2E_Compiler_geojson	5877419.0166673185 ns/iter	8465657.382716758 ns/iter	0.69
E2E_Compiler_gitpod_configuration	1047258.9774436576 ns/iter	1687191.4688997213 ns/iter	0.62
E2E_Compiler_helm_chart_lock	158896.0882018643 ns/iter	224953.37881216686 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Compiler_importmap	71490.57647899404 ns/iter	100128.65122654512 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Compiler_jasmine	266329.5489067918 ns/iter	386283.7725014029 ns/iter	0.69
E2E_Compiler_jshintrc	871936.2826361366 ns/iter	1267039.1865943917 ns/iter	0.69
E2E_Compiler_jsconfig	5317694.946564862 ns/iter	7423066.085106682 ns/iter	0.72
E2E_Compiler_krakend	33745704.190475106 ns/iter	46602819.214285776 ns/iter	0.72
E2E_Compiler_lazygit	7697919.043956283 ns/iter	10834783.969230209 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Compiler_lerna	342538.99313723965 ns/iter	480328.857339764 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Compiler_nest_cli	1723180.7654323145 ns/iter	2540120.3527272544 ns/iter	0.68
E2E_Compiler_omc	46674888.66666644 ns/iter	61674582.90909426 ns/iter	0.76
E2E_Compiler_omnisharp	1487736.6495727724 ns/iter	2223045.82594956 ns/iter	0.67
E2E_Compiler_openapi	7309233.351063395 ns/iter	10409196.343282508 ns/iter	0.70
E2E_Compiler_pre_commit_hooks	675090.7552783297 ns/iter	1091785.7308294103 ns/iter	0.62
E2E_Compiler_pulumi	832159.8260354975 ns/iter	1379793.0553360414 ns/iter	0.60
E2E_Compiler_semantic_release	302724.1192541114 ns/iter	458911.8148879901 ns/iter	0.66
E2E_Compiler_stale	270831.7649109147 ns/iter	394974.8087986274 ns/iter	0.69
E2E_Compiler_stylecop	1302500.023679409 ns/iter	1877910.361186103 ns/iter	0.69
E2E_Compiler_tmuxinator	434400.5481665547 ns/iter	621326.6108637032 ns/iter	0.70
E2E_Compiler_ui5	15556198.15555676 ns/iter	21823413.24999726 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Compiler_ui5_manifest	91997484.37499978 ns/iter	118093152.4000016 ns/iter	0.78
E2E_Compiler_unreal_engine_uproject	929974.6523995005 ns/iter	1465516.068607066 ns/iter	0.63
E2E_Compiler_users_array	174049.4379396753 ns/iter	252704.61909871138 ns/iter	0.69
E2E_Compiler_vercel	3535184.659999686 ns/iter	5033789.417266463 ns/iter	0.70
E2E_Compiler_yamllint	57270.52903752179 ns/iter	81284.45254118984 ns/iter	0.70
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	14333.309070858813 ns/iter	18218.75870394755 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_ansible_meta	136597.5565319064 ns/iter	164982.0366343447 ns/iter	0.83
E2E_Evaluator_aws_cdk	27686.1328718084 ns/iter	37119.285737085 ns/iter	0.75
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	64447.21997436846 ns/iter	90015.09240923991 ns/iter	0.72
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum_criminal_case	589942.1092003871 ns/iter	875492.3787499535 ns/iter	0.67
E2E_Evaluator_clang_format	74335.69667896673 ns/iter	88068.50458599445 ns/iter	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_cmake_presets	2788530.315589367 ns/iter	3903088.933333265 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_code_climate	105212.01819266776 ns/iter	145723.78781599517 ns/iter	0.72
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	112721.30684931498 ns/iter	148532.3128073578 ns/iter	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	346457.2432160629 ns/iter	515105.440088777 ns/iter	0.67
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	109827.43162526826 ns/iter	151826.34822970701 ns/iter	0.72
E2E_Evaluator_deno	168550.83039806108 ns/iter	280184.4306831758 ns/iter	0.60
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	205981.10196307846 ns/iter	262620.8171235313 ns/iter	0.78
E2E_Evaluator_draft_04	9178680.027397204 ns/iter	5571451.415999945 ns/iter	1.65
E2E_Evaluator_fabric_mod	390662.7416294661 ns/iter	574666.7903358192 ns/iter	0.68
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	8548331.189873824 ns/iter	8300041.365853248 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod_configuration	135661.61936757827 ns/iter	178882.45647179298 ns/iter	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_helm_chart_lock	169840.6829453301 ns/iter	384093.9923287656 ns/iter	0.44
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	25350.957604834093 ns/iter	30651.49263287538 ns/iter	0.83
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	59080.906673440906 ns/iter	87054.29063669743 ns/iter	0.68
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	722025.5601373877 ns/iter	996111.6280751523 ns/iter	0.72
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	261396.27386654037 ns/iter	319733.35809263296 ns/iter	0.82
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	105803.74291314014 ns/iter	137458.63461918174 ns/iter	0.77
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	73330.60127416592 ns/iter	102932.93564210406 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	64789.30429104286 ns/iter	141209.6992526805 ns/iter	0.46
E2E_Evaluator_nest_cli	111207.65027579774 ns/iter	141440.3886808296 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_omc	12608.271986467224 ns/iter	15128.247960634284 ns/iter	0.83
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	337805.44084507035 ns/iter	457711.320261439 ns/iter	0.74
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	8625946.739726553 ns/iter	9616171.397259964 ns/iter	0.90
E2E_Evaluator_pre_commit_hooks	291466.27479342686 ns/iter	409114.4837587001 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	420700.1880239615 ns/iter	639962.824497264 ns/iter	0.66
E2E_Evaluator_semantic_release	52308.016729866715 ns/iter	71535.45952062376 ns/iter	0.73
E2E_Evaluator_stale	89437.32543848922 ns/iter	119871.06802956076 ns/iter	0.75
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	157307.1631936372 ns/iter	207668.55309601876 ns/iter	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	54607.79990440956 ns/iter	74964.28990686154 ns/iter	0.73
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	303931.5995689529 ns/iter	374954.6398714154 ns/iter	0.81
E2E_Evaluator_ui5_manifest	1544274.0111113077 ns/iter	2072519.1483677633 ns/iter	0.75
E2E_Evaluator_unreal_engine_uproject	281809.88998812286 ns/iter	368567.800104931 ns/iter	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_users_array	383951.49558500265 ns/iter	504194.77586204064 ns/iter	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	161735.3206015723 ns/iter	268229.56449751614 ns/iter	0.60
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	4842.884794444818 ns/iter	6056.287641876857 ns/iter	0.80
JSONLD_Catalog_Simple	11139973.692308137 ns/iter	13626241.607842833 ns/iter	0.82
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Agreeing	11074755.904760856 ns/iter	14185596.791665016 ns/iter	0.78
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Shadowing	17643828.62162116 ns/iter	22443814.03124862 ns/iter	0.79
Micro_Draft4_Meta_1_No_Callback	95.57520563487563 ns/iter	140.56503727536446 ns/iter	0.68
Micro_Draft4_Required_Properties	430.72031224866663 ns/iter	595.9435981881313 ns/iter	0.72
Micro_Draft4_Many_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	14.555922568219993 ns/iter	18.236548348295628 ns/iter	0.80
Micro_Draft4_Few_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	7.379649712946825 ns/iter	8.925685657800853 ns/iter	0.83
Micro_Draft4_Items_Schema	165.26572320068908 ns/iter	252.99544412116333 ns/iter	0.65
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Object	1.5123957925436056 ns/iter	1.8589583150120124 ns/iter	0.81
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Optional	177.73284820490275 ns/iter	242.29614875994696 ns/iter	0.73
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Closed	147.78319339521232 ns/iter	198.98602922988454 ns/iter	0.74
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Required	184.96510954757287 ns/iter	253.17528145462012 ns/iter	0.73
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Closed	34.96341791068516 ns/iter	45.066029090596395 ns/iter	0.78
Micro_Draft4_Non_Recursive_Ref	9.848087240194046 ns/iter	11.866461094229033 ns/iter	0.83
Micro_Draft4_Pattern_Properties_Empty	81.20585634952866 ns/iter	116.29966942307468 ns/iter	0.70
Micro_Draft4_Ref_To_Single_Property	7.41228368394768 ns/iter	8.931616369298359 ns/iter	0.83
Micro_Draft4_Additional_Properties_Type	23.36147366367529 ns/iter	31.604761839613946 ns/iter	0.74
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Oneof	30.93913096999367 ns/iter	43.95259508371901 ns/iter	0.70
Micro_Draft4_Short_Enum	7.047364786131097 ns/iter	8.698972434866292 ns/iter	0.81
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum	7.841677320206583 ns/iter	11.605769256067848 ns/iter	0.68
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum_Short_Strings	7.278790014248449 ns/iter	8.700748694257577 ns/iter	0.84
Micro_Draft4_Type_Object	2.801651330933097 ns/iter	3.326690423485588 ns/iter	0.84
Micro_Draft4_Ref_Single_100	725632.003913916 ns/iter	1000537.7765043397 ns/iter	0.73
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Ref_Many_Nested	421408.83403741615 ns/iter	628938.9496855811 ns/iter	0.67
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Wrap	490272.4381153669 ns/iter	722160.0619834777 ns/iter	0.68
Micro_Draft6_Property_Names	73.00622375139727 ns/iter	102.83888907658486 ns/iter	0.71
Micro_Draft6_Compile_FHIR	2962671196.9999633 ns/iter	4256823670.000017 ns/iter	0.70
Micro_Draft7_If_Then_Else	13.803144919816827 ns/iter	20.09457785773417 ns/iter	0.69
Micro_2019_09_Unevaluated_Properties	15.428631901424346 ns/iter	25.055501408572994 ns/iter	0.62
Micro_2019_09_Compile_Wrap	55217951.545459576 ns/iter	61604270.499992706 ns/iter	0.90
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref	415.3796563115671 ns/iter	559.003384628192 ns/iter	0.74
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref_Single	2.5759257156800204 ns/iter	3.2240047394868414 ns/iter	0.80
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Mask	577.0088708611214 ns/iter	730.9109349969624 ns/iter	0.79
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotations	23542.624924256146 ns/iter	35629.11529854871 ns/iter	0.66
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotation_Dropping	705143.7368420432 ns/iter	989766.2772277436 ns/iter	0.71
Micro_2020_12_Compile_NonCircular_Shared_Refs	264356.72445590893 ns/iter	363248.3357588854 ns/iter	0.73
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric	5151.020019745561 ns/iter	6101.79422442629 ns/iter	0.84
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_SimpleOutput	20762.748465697812 ns/iter	27466.917396599052 ns/iter	0.76
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_TraceOutput	11301.641549148668 ns/iter	13680.19978977981 ns/iter	0.83
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail	82.57797729304252 ns/iter	100.4853323640209 ns/iter	0.82
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail_SimpleOutput	1328.1203715418144 ns/iter	1684.333929775636 ns/iter	0.79
TestSuite_Parse_WoT	6934924.780000529 ns/iter	9732394.305555342 ns/iter	0.71
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_ISO_Language_Set_3	141456609.00001076 ns/iter	187322335.7499967 ns/iter	0.76
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_OMC	23654048.266666904 ns/iter	34860826.80000208 ns/iter	0.68
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_KrakenD	278164047.3333103 ns/iter	447558972.0000244 ns/iter	0.62
Alterschema_Apply_Readibility_KrakenD	30293351196.000004 ns/iter	46491723243.00002 ns/iter	0.65
Alterschema_Check_Invalid_External_Refs	110731675.66667052 ns/iter	128146581.8000015 ns/iter	0.86
Alterschema_Check_Resolvable_External_Refs	98371.50495879361 ns/iter	128891.82502300489 ns/iter	0.76

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[github-actions]

JavaScript (linux/llvm)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d818b8b	Previous: 49094a0	Ratio
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	65743 ns	88539 ns	0.74
E2E_Evaluator_ansible-meta	334580 ns	365548 ns	0.92
E2E_Evaluator_aws-cdk	80627 ns	109542 ns	0.74
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	235022 ns	279693 ns	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum-criminal-case	1702278 ns	1748258 ns	0.97
E2E_Evaluator_clang-format	144066 ns	187622 ns	0.77
E2E_Evaluator_cmake-presets	12209075 ns	13060667 ns	0.93
E2E_Evaluator_code-climate	300712 ns	425761 ns	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	716876 ns	933399 ns	0.77
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	964983 ns	1218702 ns	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	527807 ns	682270 ns	0.77
E2E_Evaluator_deno	689540 ns	890666 ns	0.77
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	638450 ns	793995 ns	0.80
E2E_Evaluator_draft-04	13711948 ns	15407118 ns	0.89
E2E_Evaluator_fabric-mod	1538694 ns	1754960 ns	0.88
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	21129847 ns	14069985 ns	1.50
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod-configuration	433001 ns	527280 ns	0.82
E2E_Evaluator_helm-chart-lock	571307 ns	866380 ns	0.66
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	157392 ns	275732 ns	0.57
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	159109 ns	208087 ns	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	823002 ns	1038702 ns	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	1825229 ns	2409894 ns	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	339573 ns	464844 ns	0.73
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	277504 ns	324781 ns	0.85
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	265712 ns	368157 ns	0.72
E2E_Evaluator_nest-cli	351700 ns	434160 ns	0.81
E2E_Evaluator_omc	64510 ns	89065 ns	0.72
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	889835 ns	1117969 ns	0.80
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	27083992 ns	28340948 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_pre-commit-hooks	1231036 ns	1465745 ns	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	1169191 ns	1454907 ns	0.80
E2E_Evaluator_semantic-release	132270 ns	185622 ns	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_stale	238058 ns	286685 ns	0.83
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	704719 ns	843479 ns	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	122283 ns	190332 ns	0.64
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	1153106 ns	1647465 ns	0.70
E2E_Evaluator_ui5-manifest	5487921 ns	7802973 ns	0.70
E2E_Evaluator_unreal-engine-uproject	954451 ns	1189443 ns	0.80
E2E_Evaluator_users-array	1474483 ns	2468994 ns	0.60
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	596070 ns	796517 ns	0.75
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	15551 ns	18541 ns	0.84

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[github-actions]

Benchmark (linux/gcc)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d818b8b	Previous: 49094a0	Ratio
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_ISO_Language_Set_3	184794771.99997517 ns/iter	245616312.3333681 ns/iter	0.75
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_OMC	41386527.2941273 ns/iter	51692711.76922708 ns/iter	0.80
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_KrakenD	526517651.9999386 ns/iter	594552446.9998418 ns/iter	0.89
Alterschema_Apply_Readibility_KrakenD	53545382459.99993 ns/iter	63857459902.00008 ns/iter	0.84
Alterschema_Check_Invalid_External_Refs	142886157.6000145 ns/iter	209673805.3333714 ns/iter	0.68
Alterschema_Check_Resolvable_External_Refs	178285.58263728407 ns/iter	221041.39751749294 ns/iter	0.81
TestSuite_Parse_WoT	11358771.854841713 ns/iter	13791180.392155522 ns/iter	0.82
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref	774.6337412615172 ns/iter	942.8714799093343 ns/iter	0.82
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref_Single	3.4916062577013123 ns/iter	3.873309365085509 ns/iter	0.90
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Mask	1026.4356334607987 ns/iter	1251.984548841264 ns/iter	0.82
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotations	46117.2577154616 ns/iter	53333.800997650666 ns/iter	0.86
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotation_Dropping	1315446.9578540938 ns/iter	1476497.7710085474 ns/iter	0.89
Micro_2020_12_Compile_NonCircular_Shared_Refs	450931.0135746651 ns/iter	550204.3403590821 ns/iter	0.82
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric	7545.844475155792 ns/iter	9492.009906903173 ns/iter	0.79
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_SimpleOutput	35389.193162822456 ns/iter	44800.634103936936 ns/iter	0.79
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_TraceOutput	18017.620123520996 ns/iter	22415.96504169229 ns/iter	0.80
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail	128.34021760914138 ns/iter	178.63709460661946 ns/iter	0.72
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail_SimpleOutput	2200.128114516211 ns/iter	2566.3162869517996 ns/iter	0.86
Micro_2019_09_Unevaluated_Properties	24.96466541289364 ns/iter	30.631783497272362 ns/iter	0.81
Micro_2019_09_Compile_Wrap	70335784.00000806 ns/iter	90929037.14287916 ns/iter	0.77
Micro_Draft7_If_Then_Else	23.265958147014796 ns/iter	25.83138008497609 ns/iter	0.90
Micro_Draft6_Property_Names	134.2699947271159 ns/iter	151.46281101424742 ns/iter	0.89
Micro_Draft6_Compile_FHIR	4655553162.999923 ns/iter	5356802839.0000105 ns/iter	0.87
Micro_Draft4_Meta_1_No_Callback	159.36217302587943 ns/iter	181.84184749258023 ns/iter	0.88
Micro_Draft4_Required_Properties	916.1645561892733 ns/iter	907.4338782343754 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Many_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	20.61415192106733 ns/iter	21.89289149455496 ns/iter	0.94
Micro_Draft4_Few_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	12.078611988130717 ns/iter	15.843178517324809 ns/iter	0.76
Micro_Draft4_Items_Schema	367.67791395068747 ns/iter	308.637765329913 ns/iter	1.19
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Object	1.9411122245125623 ns/iter	1.461664512984393 ns/iter	1.33
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Optional	244.75311557527428 ns/iter	495.94768294296125 ns/iter	0.49
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Closed	202.21479055798858 ns/iter	349.66001924058617 ns/iter	0.58
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Required	267.91575875601836 ns/iter	451.950365698896 ns/iter	0.59
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Closed	57.31623744581394 ns/iter	65.3968360618072 ns/iter	0.88
Micro_Draft4_Non_Recursive_Ref	8.073580043021698 ns/iter	8.795603013901891 ns/iter	0.92
Micro_Draft4_Pattern_Properties_Empty	161.58630185338254 ns/iter	193.93651424970687 ns/iter	0.83
Micro_Draft4_Ref_To_Single_Property	12.564465725132386 ns/iter	15.823558986239549 ns/iter	0.79
Micro_Draft4_Additional_Properties_Type	12.285560143929398 ns/iter	13.747654993021165 ns/iter	0.89
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Oneof	58.974726880880354 ns/iter	63.4192826501746 ns/iter	0.93
Micro_Draft4_Short_Enum	10.690344026756716 ns/iter	14.581574786206717 ns/iter	0.73
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum	10.59180645296858 ns/iter	12.676475680545432 ns/iter	0.84
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum_Short_Strings	10.6538547705464 ns/iter	14.437528011765881 ns/iter	0.74
Micro_Draft4_Type_Object	4.147598512881542 ns/iter	4.5707127164877965 ns/iter	0.91
Micro_Draft4_Ref_Single_100	1133411.0566341905 ns/iter	1422435.0999998024 ns/iter	0.80
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Ref_Many_Nested	739507.3981289231 ns/iter	894970.0064518002 ns/iter	0.83
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Wrap	897531.0770219318 ns/iter	1135642.0210016868 ns/iter	0.79
JSONLD_Catalog_Simple	15626081.86956684 ns/iter	21097985.000002656 ns/iter	0.74
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Agreeing	15721156.222222514 ns/iter	23660580.451610994 ns/iter	0.66
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Shadowing	23908764.63333219 ns/iter	33885360.68420858 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Compiler_adaptivecard	30706420.17391749 ns/iter	42588690.05555728 ns/iter	0.72
E2E_Compiler_ansible_meta	10070989.605633834 ns/iter	12348779.892854672 ns/iter	0.82
E2E_Compiler_aws_cdk	151376.69255947042 ns/iter	197393.18278663617 ns/iter	0.77
E2E_Compiler_babelrc	915141.9569312946 ns/iter	1127021.070739765 ns/iter	0.81
E2E_Compiler_clang_format	6369793.304763031 ns/iter	7863347.761361762 ns/iter	0.81
E2E_Compiler_cmake_presets	13351612.150944555 ns/iter	17086806.523810167 ns/iter	0.78
E2E_Compiler_code_climate	682598.1735775744 ns/iter	801551.6766745644 ns/iter	0.85
E2E_Compiler_cql2	6919970.576923071 ns/iter	8282022.905881177 ns/iter	0.84
E2E_Compiler_cspell	9983844.666666383 ns/iter	12349803.767859515 ns/iter	0.81
E2E_Compiler_cypress	1496425.3878410074 ns/iter	1860358.7679996658 ns/iter	0.80
E2E_Compiler_deno	3253668.266967919 ns/iter	3946985.544944306 ns/iter	0.82
E2E_Compiler_dependabot	1261972.0210155614 ns/iter	1536004.6381579994 ns/iter	0.82
E2E_Compiler_draft_04	1232350.858195455 ns/iter	1428227.7565919633 ns/iter	0.86
E2E_Compiler_fabric_mod	2110627.0294984444 ns/iter	2428664.9999996573 ns/iter	0.87
E2E_Compiler_geojson	9687675.19178023 ns/iter	11974771.620688882 ns/iter	0.81
E2E_Compiler_gitpod_configuration	2039963.089595603 ns/iter	2327053.913333354 ns/iter	0.88
E2E_Compiler_helm_chart_lock	246497.3762627029 ns/iter	324763.8481771898 ns/iter	0.76
E2E_Compiler_importmap	118228.65965154486 ns/iter	149142.12715656823 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Compiler_jasmine	446642.32944983727 ns/iter	583877.49454237 ns/iter	0.76
E2E_Compiler_jshintrc	1424933.4809617263 ns/iter	1796798.2743590628 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Compiler_jsconfig	8174763.604650908 ns/iter	10448298.090909014 ns/iter	0.78
E2E_Compiler_krakend	50163619.41666976 ns/iter	69181772.33332142 ns/iter	0.73
E2E_Compiler_lazygit	12023129.844825737 ns/iter	15561110.847823765 ns/iter	0.77
E2E_Compiler_lerna	563363.2358184346 ns/iter	727092.1041666156 ns/iter	0.77
E2E_Compiler_nest_cli	2934224.021186757 ns/iter	3583978.7743579787 ns/iter	0.82
E2E_Compiler_omc	71016327.88888107 ns/iter	100813115.16667788 ns/iter	0.70
E2E_Compiler_omnisharp	2600040.3888887106 ns/iter	3156965.765765972 ns/iter	0.82
E2E_Compiler_openapi	12519309.4545466 ns/iter	15935496.071430558 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Compiler_pre_commit_hooks	1283307.329729494 ns/iter	1569298.9910316216 ns/iter	0.82
E2E_Compiler_pulumi	1661600.2536232148 ns/iter	1926685.6758240913 ns/iter	0.86
E2E_Compiler_semantic_release	603152.2165039013 ns/iter	689882.7180745285 ns/iter	0.87
E2E_Compiler_stale	439932.3177749512 ns/iter	574014.1498771769 ns/iter	0.77
E2E_Compiler_stylecop	2250036.0392156653 ns/iter	2759058.3110232605 ns/iter	0.82
E2E_Compiler_tmuxinator	791911.8357705937 ns/iter	948027.2970432006 ns/iter	0.84
E2E_Compiler_ui5	24527935.10713848 ns/iter	31216599.523802526 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Compiler_ui5_manifest	134288103.59996533 ns/iter	189860330.49998242 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Compiler_unreal_engine_uproject	1668675.7710277205 ns/iter	2050855.8826980833 ns/iter	0.81
E2E_Compiler_users_array	311976.4645940852 ns/iter	392891.70174448454 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Compiler_vercel	5680170.1709395675 ns/iter	6818253.07842968 ns/iter	0.83
E2E_Compiler_yamllint	93389.54461654973 ns/iter	122237.64041813195 ns/iter	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	20816.136048498443 ns/iter	26924.90765566937 ns/iter	0.77
E2E_Evaluator_ansible_meta	204521.27094314242 ns/iter	267249.5372907458 ns/iter	0.77
E2E_Evaluator_aws_cdk	47722.94153543747 ns/iter	56700.31246456774 ns/iter	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	87243.67795565932 ns/iter	103643.66259345702 ns/iter	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum_criminal_case	988153.728155305 ns/iter	1241226.8464284383 ns/iter	0.80
E2E_Evaluator_clang_format	80539.58031260784 ns/iter	92903.91612387914 ns/iter	0.87
E2E_Evaluator_cmake_presets	4777555.595890041 ns/iter	6536605.958333533 ns/iter	0.73
E2E_Evaluator_code_climate	180478.36942340503 ns/iter	204589.3897059159 ns/iter	0.88
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	183749.30923279788 ns/iter	220011.36008737836 ns/iter	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	537077.6308412224 ns/iter	611505.486910913 ns/iter	0.88
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	153579.39232591543 ns/iter	155008.22724225352 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_deno	334123.19766871823 ns/iter	309701.22832886135 ns/iter	1.08
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	307180.5999101152 ns/iter	376533.88417615514 ns/iter	0.82
E2E_Evaluator_draft_04	5421956.555554941 ns/iter	11141883.423730271 ns/iter	0.49
E2E_Evaluator_fabric_mod	654127.2940074869 ns/iter	773459.7050997191 ns/iter	0.85
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	9673274.333336202 ns/iter	13618918.333332106 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod_configuration	214646.52497641504 ns/iter	255800.33062434944 ns/iter	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_helm_chart_lock	382333.9578378648 ns/iter	254475.41243989262 ns/iter	1.50
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	28359.164736161758 ns/iter	39318.381844537056 ns/iter	0.72
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	101102.82559309623 ns/iter	115427.57575257831 ns/iter	0.88
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	999689.2312136552 ns/iter	1044441.4548192482 ns/iter	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	330584.4140549934 ns/iter	408913.29642646335 ns/iter	0.81
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	158634.84688134602 ns/iter	202709.2644676129 ns/iter	0.78
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	108175.9718788466 ns/iter	137131.91389669402 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	185516.13834195948 ns/iter	138759.05954499214 ns/iter	1.34
E2E_Evaluator_nest_cli	167325.62795802724 ns/iter	198885.87308346378 ns/iter	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_omc	17565.413808415982 ns/iter	24875.431316480215 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	542247.4870030105 ns/iter	564630.3932951868 ns/iter	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	10643221.015623538 ns/iter	18802857.658534423 ns/iter	0.57
E2E_Evaluator_pre_commit_hooks	477115.9979838096 ns/iter	503539.56056131714 ns/iter	0.95
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	709193.7323077264 ns/iter	813859.5359550788 ns/iter	0.87
E2E_Evaluator_semantic_release	83341.87235064026 ns/iter	92621.54165554458 ns/iter	0.90
E2E_Evaluator_stale	136339.935258966 ns/iter	179548.87542261928 ns/iter	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	242852.91824767782 ns/iter	323391.9265639107 ns/iter	0.75
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	87523.5789408741 ns/iter	96201.03648835108 ns/iter	0.91
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	443361.1844993017 ns/iter	591024.6790542438 ns/iter	0.75
E2E_Evaluator_ui5_manifest	2517422.7027033465 ns/iter	3225084.6681038104 ns/iter	0.78
E2E_Evaluator_unreal_engine_uproject	400491.25323580124 ns/iter	497361.74269830284 ns/iter	0.81
E2E_Evaluator_users_array	557920.5684211534 ns/iter	703929.027300184 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	316547.8160971027 ns/iter	300101.434485714 ns/iter	1.05
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	10037.481279899132 ns/iter	12258.601106677299 ns/iter	0.82
Schema_Format_ISO_Language_To_JSON	38945026.000028014 ns/iter	48865329.07688399 ns/iter	0.80
Schema_Bundle_Meta_2020_12	605835.9157075033 ns/iter	692752.8586970766 ns/iter	0.87
Schema_Bundle_Many_Remotes_With_Fragments	6540756.076925793 ns/iter	7994887.712636656 ns/iter	0.82
Schema_Frame_WoT_References	2273164.790476008 ns/iter	2580557.8007384273 ns/iter	0.88
Schema_Frame_OMC_References	9180338.102565564 ns/iter	11369681.918032987 ns/iter	0.81
Schema_Frame_OMC_Pointers	17452679.07316946 ns/iter	21354124.818179283 ns/iter	0.82
Schema_Frame_OMC_Locations	8021519.755554133 ns/iter	9709281.208333526 ns/iter	0.83
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations	34904009.499996394 ns/iter	46886182.3125053 ns/iter	0.74
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Root	386.161574098796 ns/iter	437.24083279741967 ns/iter	0.88
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_References	14263715.673469422 ns/iter	19631680.88571235 ns/iter	0.73
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_Reachable	102486413.85715018 ns/iter	124001300.00005448 ns/iter	0.83
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations_To_JSON	27758473.291669358 ns/iter	37670389.578950465 ns/iter	0.74
Schema_Frame_Many_Resources_References	133906171.59998329 ns/iter	161240326.75003263 ns/iter	0.83
Schema_Frame_Deeply_Nested_References	9370174.12162289 ns/iter	11251038.730160005 ns/iter	0.83
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language	4467884.651613794 ns/iter	5083522.4782600645 ns/iter	0.88
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language_To_JSON	15898585.533336194 ns/iter	16679869.186048586 ns/iter	0.95

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[github-actions]

JavaScript (linux/gcc)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d818b8b	Previous: 49094a0	Ratio
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	98709 ns	120250 ns	0.82
E2E_Evaluator_ansible-meta	400170 ns	556068 ns	0.72
E2E_Evaluator_aws-cdk	120292 ns	131077 ns	0.92
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	306150 ns	361214 ns	0.85
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum-criminal-case	1942795 ns	2634835 ns	0.74
E2E_Evaluator_clang-format	202733 ns	265373 ns	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_cmake-presets	15096243 ns	18394475 ns	0.82
E2E_Evaluator_code-climate	446444 ns	525829 ns	0.85
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	977164 ns	1248827 ns	0.78
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	1285986 ns	1640680 ns	0.78
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	721922 ns	850736 ns	0.85
E2E_Evaluator_deno	978901 ns	1107331 ns	0.88
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	884762 ns	1088819 ns	0.81
E2E_Evaluator_draft-04	16532742 ns	19824542 ns	0.83
E2E_Evaluator_fabric-mod	1926398 ns	2431451 ns	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	16148712 ns	23982952 ns	0.67
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod-configuration	563619 ns	740433 ns	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_helm-chart-lock	940754 ns	1007525 ns	0.93
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	300733 ns	287431 ns	1.05
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	227104 ns	282535 ns	0.80
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	1125624 ns	1495668 ns	0.75
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	2688903 ns	3038112 ns	0.89
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	514099 ns	636848 ns	0.81
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	359986 ns	475606 ns	0.76
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	405153 ns	455234 ns	0.89
E2E_Evaluator_nest-cli	474115 ns	630240 ns	0.75
E2E_Evaluator_omc	95466 ns	116725 ns	0.82
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	1231548 ns	1524043 ns	0.81
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	31699650 ns	44910177 ns	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_pre-commit-hooks	1621847 ns	2196970 ns	0.74
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	1637843 ns	2071475 ns	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_semantic-release	210665 ns	239353 ns	0.88
E2E_Evaluator_stale	311203 ns	397761 ns	0.78
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	1062683 ns	1274064 ns	0.83
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	201480 ns	232383 ns	0.87
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	1748277 ns	2228883 ns	0.78
E2E_Evaluator_ui5-manifest	8343980 ns	12608716 ns	0.66
E2E_Evaluator_unreal-engine-uproject	1321869 ns	1649936 ns	0.80
E2E_Evaluator_users-array	2527234 ns	3151512 ns	0.80
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	867507 ns	1053321 ns	0.82
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	19639 ns	24393 ns	0.81

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[augmentcode]

🤖 Augment PR Summary

Summary: This PR extends canonicalization of unevaluatedProperties.
It recognizes schemas whose sole in-place branch is allOf: [{ $ref: ... }].
The referenced target is resolved through SchemaFrame to honor effective base URIs.
Known target properties names are copied to the local schema as true schemas.
The original unevaluatedProperties keyword is then renamed to additionalProperties.
The referenced branch itself remains unchanged, preserving its validation constraints.
The rule rejects targets with further references, in-place applicators, or property-evaluating keywords.
It also limits the optimization to modern JSON Schema applicator vocabularies.
New 2019-09 and 2020-12 canonicalizer tests cover the successful transformation.
Additional negative tests cover anyOf, additionalProperties, patterns, conditionals, and uncovered required names.
The canonicalizer build list and rule registration now include the new transform.
The aim is to eliminate a common real-world unevaluatedProperties pattern that previously survived canonicalization.

_{🤖 Was this summary useful? React with 👍 or 👎}

[augmentcode]

Review completed. No suggestions at this time.

Comment augment review to trigger a new review at any time.

[augmentcode]

Review completed. 1 suggestion posted.

Comment augment review to trigger a new review at any time.

[augmentcode]

src/canonicalizer/rules/unevaluated_properties_to_additional_properties_single_ref.h:132: This only defers the rewrite: required_properties_in_properties subsequently adds the uncovered name to the target's properties, the canonicalizer restarts, and this rule then succeeds and copies it locally. For a target requiring extra but initially defining only shared, the resulting additionalProperties accepts extra, while the original unevaluatedProperties: false rejects it because required does not evaluate that property.

Severity: high

_{🤖 Was this useful? React with 👍 or 👎, or 🚀 if it prevented an incident/outage.}

[cubic-dev-ai]

All reported issues were addressed across 5 files

<sub>Reply with feedback, questions, or to request a fix.

Re-trigger cubic</sub>

[Vansh-kap-98]

hey @jviotti ive verified the pr, could i please ask you review it once, the pr is associated with issue #407. whenever you find the time to

[jviotti]

Hey @Vansh-kap-98 sorry for the delay! Looking into it in a bit. Exciting!

[jviotti]

I'd avoid this macro. Doing the equality checks at the canonicalizer level should be enough.

Though I understand what you are trying to do here to triple check evaluation results. Note we have https://github.com/sourcemeta/blaze/blob/main/test/evaluator/tracesuite_canonical.cc for this purpose. i.e. if you extend the JSON trace files like evaluator_2020_12.json to have MORE unevaluatedProperties THEN we run those before/after canonicalisation to check conformity, so I would move the test you have for this over there!

[Vansh-kap-98]

ohhh, that makes a lot of sense, thank you for the review. I've dropped the macro and moved the check into the trace files. evaluator_2020_12.json has 5 more unevaluatedProperties cases for the single-$ref shape, so tracesuite_canonical now checks the before/after conformity automatically.

Also merged main to clear the conflict, that turned up the #1042 renames (is_in_place_applicator, the vocabulary enum), which I've fixed.

[jviotti]

I'm running some of my own tests on this. Let's see if we can manage to break it. As these transformations can be very tricky to get right in all cases

[jviotti]

Looks correct to me! Can you look into the git conflict though? And through the other comments I left? Then I think we are good to merge :)

[Vansh-kap-98]

@jviotti

• Merged main to clear the conflict. That surfaced the Upgrade Core to cae13670287d83d90c0ea17940c36c48dd48ba37 #1042 renames (is_in_place_applicator and the vocabulary enum members), plus a few implicit pointer-to-bool conversions clang-tidy flagged — all fixed.
• Dropped CANONICALIZE_AND_COMPARE_EVALUATION and moved the check into the trace files as you suggested: evaluator_2020_12.json has 5 more unevaluatedProperties cases for the single-$ref shape, so tracesuite_canonical now covers the before/after conformity automatically. Better home for it — thanks.

Ready for another look whenever you have time.

hope you have a lovely day

[jviotti]

Hi @Vansh-kap-98 , awesome! Merging now! And thanks for the work. Following the guidance of that paper with more rules is always appreciated

[Vansh-kap-98]

@jviotti thank you, and thanks for taking the time to review this so carefully, ill continue to follow the guidance of the paper, currently testing out Multi-branch 'allof'. if there's ever something you'd like looked at that you haven't the time for yourself, I'd be glad to help.