Repository navigation
Conversation
Current-head release review record — declared internal fallbackExact approved source commit: CI and snapshot evidence
Bounded independent internal reviewThe orchestrator reports the final independent internal refuter result as VERIFIED WITH CAVEATS, with no blockers on these same source bytes. Reported scope includes all 21 manifest files, 15 targeted checks, and 6 production adversarial checks. The adversarial checks passed after a timeout-only extension of the harness; source bytes were unchanged. Evidence directory: Caveats: this does not establish exhaustive painted-frame equivalence, and there was no external-model review. The canonical fixture's five original trailing-whitespace lines remain intentionally byte-identical. Approval provenance and authorized fallbackAt the release gate, GitHub reports 0 current-head reviews, no inline review comments, and no unresolved review threads. No external-model or bot review approval is claimed. The earlier AI security review route was unavailable because of unsupported-model infrastructure. The user explicitly accepted this declared internal fallback under the Stage 2 flow and authorized a normal merge commit for PR #129 into the existing milestone only. GitHub reports no configured required checks; both current-head check runs are successful. Merge remains subject to normal repository policy and an exact-head guard. The feature branch is retained for audit. Product post-integration checks are delegated separately to the coder. |
|
This PR does not match any of the 1 configured review trigger rule. |
4a950c1
into
milestone/stu-implement-updated-ui-ux
| } else { | ||
| document.getElementById("results-view")?.classList.remove("visible"); | ||
| document.getElementById("ready-state")?.classList.remove("hidden"); | ||
| document.getElementById("main-stage-container")?.classList.remove("visible"); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🔴 Abandoned runs expose unreviewed results
Leaving during Code Review makes switchView display Results because pipelineState.artifactBundle already exists. The review request is aborted, so Home presents unreviewed code as a completed result.
Learn more
Generator populates pipelineState.artifactBundle before Code Review completes in runThinkingPipeline. On navigation, updateSelectedArtifactPanels renders that bundle as Results even though pipelineState.step3Result has not arrived. The newly preserved panel marker then makes switchView('home') reveal those results. The no-bundle branch clears the marker, but the presence of a generated bundle does not prove a completed run.
Example: Architect and Generator succeed, then the user opens Account while Review is pending. Review is aborted; returning Home displays Results with the generated code instead of returning to the composer or a reviewed previous result.
Recommended fix: In switchView, distinguish a reviewed, completed result from a partially populated bundle before calling updateSelectedArtifactPanels. Clear the marker and return to the composer for an abandoned first run; if replacing an earlier result, restore its completed snapshot instead.
Was this helpful? React with 👍 or 👎 to provide feedback.
Summary
-0.025em.Coder-reported local verification — round 3
These results apply to the frozen snapshot published in this PR; they are not independent reviewer approval.
Evidence and snapshot identity
Local evidence directory:
/Users/home/Projects/ccc-diagnostics/stu445-r2/round3//Users/home/Projects/ccc-diagnostics/stu445-r2/round3/final-manifest.jsond91313db4539c5c01023bd97a747c42c482fe06eca4a471c28188572337381dd/Users/home/Projects/ccc-diagnostics/stu445-r2/round3/full-verification/(02-unit.log,03-build.log,05-browser.log,06-accessibility.log,07-deploy-guard.log,08-proxies.log,09-leaks.log)./Users/home/Projects/ccc-diagnostics/stu445-r2/round3/red.logand/Users/home/Projects/ccc-diagnostics/stu445-r2/round3/green.log.dist/assets/index-vWxoLxnc.js, SHA25683506f0431dbdf0c4ea0d72eafe79659471f62732f1ecbdb224d8e8ffbcb8e85.cee6fc2f9659ddd05a1dbaf124e677af1546e73d; sole parent:dc3c48834fcfd6b44110c567cd9d20e8125255e2.Draft review status and canonical whitespace exception
548e628fe94f2b5e647cb4849fbc3200b43dcead60ea53c076f0085aca8917dc.milestone/stu-implement-updated-ui-uxbranch.