Environment
- Minecraft: 1.18.2
- Forge: CakeWorld's configured 1.18.2 test runtime
- OreSpawn candidate:
4.0.12.118021
- OreSpawn commit:
7c82ecc844ae9d241a108f4417c6c3b5b0bc29a2
- OreSpawn JAR SHA-256:
0478D611A96020DAAE794B72E64EFD677B49A5B63BCB6179330D63317B16D6A6
- CakeWorld branch/commit:
master-1.18.2 / 0a3fb0dd6788d2fcad78f82d20154a772ff93d05
- CakeWorld provider revision: 57
Defect
Dimension snow_block and ice_block overrides are accepted and baked, but vanilla Snow and Ice placed in an exposed loaded chunk remain unchanged after OreSpawn's public Forge ChunkEvent.Load route runs.
The server log confirms that the CakeWorld provider is active and the dynamic Overworld bake contains 1 material overrides, so this is not a provider-discovery or configuration-validation failure.
Reproduction
CakeWorld contains a focused black-box GameTest:
https://github.com/SkyBlade1978/CakeWorld/blob/master-1.18.2/src/main/java/com/mcmoddev/cakeworld/gametest/WeatherMaterialGameTests.java
It:
- Starts a server with CakeWorld's normal
cakeworld:edible_world provider.
- Places exposed vanilla Stone supports with vanilla Snow and Ice above them in a loaded Overworld chunk.
- Posts the public Forge
ChunkEvent.Load used by OreSpawn's weather-material converter.
- Checks for CakeWorld Icing Layer and Frozen Lemonade respectively.
Run from the CakeWorld checkout:
.\gradlew.bat runGameTestServer --no-daemon `
"-PcakeworldLocalOreSpawnJar=D:\MinecraftMineralogy\OS118\OreSpawn\build\libs\OreSpawn-4.0.12.118021.jar" `
-PcakeworldFreshWorldgenRuntime=true `
-PcakeworldFreshWorldgenRunDirectory=run-os412-weather-materials-r1 `
"-PcakeworldGameTestNamespaces=cakeworld_weather_materials"
Actual result
The required GameTest fails:
configuredsnowandicereplacevanillaweatherproducts failed!
OreSpawn weather conversion failed: snow=false, ice=false,
snowState=Block{minecraft:snow}[layers=1], iceState=Block{minecraft:ice}
Both blocks remain vanilla.
The same log records:
CakeWorld OreSpawn provider revision 57 is active
Baked Overworld ... 3 palettes, 18 surfaces, and 1 material overrides
Expected result
With CakeWorld's configured dimension material overrides:
minecraft:snow should convert to cakeworld:icing_layer
minecraft:ice should convert to cakeworld:frozen_lemonade
Likely investigation area
WorldMaterialWeather.onChunkLoad / convertChunk receives the event, obtains the baked dimension manager, and scans the heightmap column. The configuration is present, so the remaining seam appears to be event/heightmap scanning or replacement eligibility rather than provider parsing.
Suggested acceptance coverage
- The linked focused black-box GameTest passes.
- Naturally generated weather products convert in a fresh world and still behave correctly after save/reload.
- Dimensions without a configured override retain vanilla Snow/Ice.
- Conversion remains limited to weather products and does not broadly rewrite player or structure blocks.
Environment
4.0.12.1180217c82ecc844ae9d241a108f4417c6c3b5b0bc29a20478D611A96020DAAE794B72E64EFD677B49A5B63BCB6179330D63317B16D6A6master-1.18.2/0a3fb0dd6788d2fcad78f82d20154a772ff93d05Defect
Dimension
snow_blockandice_blockoverrides are accepted and baked, but vanilla Snow and Ice placed in an exposed loaded chunk remain unchanged after OreSpawn's public ForgeChunkEvent.Loadroute runs.The server log confirms that the CakeWorld provider is active and the dynamic Overworld bake contains
1 material overrides, so this is not a provider-discovery or configuration-validation failure.Reproduction
CakeWorld contains a focused black-box GameTest:
https://github.com/SkyBlade1978/CakeWorld/blob/master-1.18.2/src/main/java/com/mcmoddev/cakeworld/gametest/WeatherMaterialGameTests.java
It:
cakeworld:edible_worldprovider.ChunkEvent.Loadused by OreSpawn's weather-material converter.Run from the CakeWorld checkout:
Actual result
The required GameTest fails:
Both blocks remain vanilla.
The same log records:
Expected result
With CakeWorld's configured dimension material overrides:
minecraft:snowshould convert tocakeworld:icing_layerminecraft:iceshould convert tocakeworld:frozen_lemonadeLikely investigation area
WorldMaterialWeather.onChunkLoad/convertChunkreceives the event, obtains the baked dimension manager, and scans the heightmap column. The configuration is present, so the remaining seam appears to be event/heightmap scanning or replacement eligibility rather than provider parsing.Suggested acceptance coverage